top of page

Enough Gears Already? Have Automatic Transmissions Gone Too Far?

The Engine Report
Sep 29
4 min read

I might be getting old, but I remember when simply having a four-speed automatic transmission was something manufacturers advertised as a selling feature. Eventually, the three-speed disappeared, four speeds became normal, and for quite a while it seemed like that was all anyone really needed.

Then came the five-speed automatic. Before long, we had six, seven, eight, and finally nine- and ten-speed transmissions. At roughly the same time, CVTs became commonplace. Today, an ordinary family vehicle having eight or ten ratios barely warrants a mention.

But it makes me wonder: do we actually need this many gears?


Why Did We Get So Many Gears?

The obvious answer is fuel economy.Adding ratios allows an engine to operate closer to its most efficient speed more of the time. A very low first gear can provide good acceleration without requiring an extremely short final-drive ratio, while tall upper gears keep engine RPM low on the highway. There are also benefits for emissions, acceleration, and drivability. Modern computer-controlled transmissions can select from numerous ratios almost instantaneously in a way that simply wasn't practical with the hydraulically controlled automatics of decades past. So there are legitimate engineering reasons for adding gears. But I also suspect there was a period when gear count became a marketing tool. If your competitor had a six-speed, having an eight-speed sounded more sophisticated. If eight was good, surely ten must be better. That doesn't necessarily mean ten gears are actually better for the owner.


Were Old Automatics Really That Bad?

It's easy to look back at three- and four-speed automatics as primitive, but many were remarkably durable. Think of transmissions such as the GM Turbo-Hydramatic 350 and 400, Ford's C6, or Chrysler's Torqueflite 727 and 904. These were simple three-speed transmissions by today's standards, yet some developed excellent reputations for durability.Moving into the 1980s and 1990s complicates the picture.

Four-speed automatics such as Ford's AOD, GM's 700R4/4L60 family, and Chrysler's various four-speed designs demonstrated that adding gears and overdrive didn't automatically produce better reliability. Some were excellent in certain applications; others developed very well-known weaknesses.The same thing happened with five- and six-speed automatics. Some proved extremely durable. Others didn't.

Which brings me to something that's easy to overlook:More gears don't inherently make a transmission unreliable. Complexity does, however, create more opportunities for things to go wrong.


Eight and Ten Speeds Changed the Game Again

Modern eight-speed transmissions show just how good a complicated automatic can be in some cases. ZF's 8HP eight-speed, for example, has appeared in everything from ordinary family vehicles to luxury cars and high-performance applications. It manages to provide a very wide ratio spread while shifting quickly and smoothly. In other words, an eight-speed doesn't have to be fragile simply because it has twice as many forward gears as the four-speeds many of us grew up with. Ten-speed transmissions pushed the idea even further. The goal isn't really to have the driver experience ten distinctly different gears. Instead, the closely spaced ratios allow the computer to keep the engine operating where it wants it. And that's perhaps where we've reached the point of diminishing returns.


Do We Really Need More Than Eight?

Going from three speeds to four was significant. Adding overdrive made an enormous difference to highway cruising.Going from four to five or six also provided obvious advantages. Manufacturers could combine strong acceleration with lower highway RPM and better fuel economy.Going from six to eight can still produce meaningful improvements. But eight to ten? The advantages become considerably smaller.

Eventually, adding another gear produces so little improvement that the additional mechanical complexity becomes difficult to justify - think diminishing returns. That's especially true now that hybrid systems can use electric motors to fill torque gaps and keep gasoline engines operating efficiently. And then there's the CVT.

A continuously variable transmission effectively has an unlimited number of ratios within its operating range. From a purely efficiency-focused perspective, that's an elegant solution. Yet many drivers dislike the way CVTs feel, which has led manufacturers to program simulated gear changes into transmissions specifically designed not to need gears. There's something a bit ironic about that.


Reliability Depends More on Execution Than Gear Count

I don't think the lesson is that old three-speed transmissions were reliable and modern ten-speeds are unreliable. History doesn't really support that. There were terrible old transmissions and extraordinarily durable ones. The same is true today.

What concerns me more is the speed of development. Automakers are under enormous pressure to improve fuel economy, emissions, and performance while simultaneously reducing development costs. New transmission families can appear relatively quickly, and occasionally weaknesses don't become apparent until hundreds of thousands of vehicles are already on the roadAn old three-speed automatic might have been inefficient, but after decades of production, there wasn't much left for engineers to discover about it.Modern transmissions are vastly more capable. They're also considerably more complicated.


Maybe Eight Is Enough

If I had to pick a sweet spot for a conventional automatic transmission, I'd argue that we've probably already reached it.A well-designed eight-speed automatic provides a huge ratio spread, low cruising RPM, excellent acceleration, and enough intermediate ratios to keep a modern engine in its efficient operating range.Ten speeds can improve on that, but we're talking about increasingly small gains.And if someone eventually announces a twelve-speed automatic for a family crossover, I'm sure there will be an impressive engineering explanation for why it's necessary.I'm just not convinced I'll want one.Sometimes enough gears really is enough.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page